Skip to main content

What Lathe should I buy?

Opinions on lathe?
Author Last Post

Hi Emily -


I own a Nova Comet II Lathe as well as a large Nova DVR II. I bought the Nova Comet as a replacement for my original Delta Midi lathe which had burned up. The Comet II is a good lathe for smaller items, like pens and small spindle turnings, which is why I bought it. It has a #2 Morse taper on both the head and tail stock, making it capable of using add ons for much larger lathes. It also has a 1"x 8" headstock thread, which is a good standard for a midi lathe for lots of chuck options. I use a Oneway Talon chuck on mine and it is well suited for the lathe and size projects. Another plus is it has a dial type variable speed change, allowing selection of various speeds per belt position. That said, it does not support continuous speed changes from 0 to top RPM, but does require belt changes at key points in the speed range. The manufacturers did this to maximize the torgue per speed range due to the smaller motor on the lathe.


This is not a lathe for doing large turnings, nor roughing out larger pieces of wood - it just doesn't have the power, but it is very capable for spindle turning of smaller pieces like a pen or 1.5" or smaller spindle. If you think you will be doing larger turnings, this isn't the lathe, but it is very strong on projects suited for its size and power.


I have not had any issues with the lathe in the roughly 2 years I have owned it. I do all my polishing and buffing on this lathe for all the turnings I do on my larger lathe, and use it also for a lot of pen making tasks without issue. I have heard of some people having issues with the headstock bearings failing after a while, but most reviews seem to be good.


My only advise is buy once, cry once. Carefully think of what lathe tasks and projects you ultimately want to do with the lathe and spend as much as you can on a lathe that will get you there. Bed length, bed swing, and power are givens that you cannot change, so be sure it will do what you want before puitting some cash down.





It looks like Rockler has it new at $619.  The 2 Novas we have at the club I think work well.  

I do love my Delta though

Jesse
Sent from my iPhone

I also have a 46-460 and really like it.  I agree that you should fix it for a very reasonable price rather than replace it.  This assumes that other than the reverse you like it.
Tom Puskar 



Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone


Hi


My delta 46-460 is being a pain and I'm thinking of trying a different lathe. The reverse does not work on it and there is an issue with the handwheel.

I came across this on Craigslist, but I'm getting mixed feedback on whether it's actually a good lathe or not. The guy said he never used it and it does come with extras.


Is this worth it(was thinking of offering 400) or better to keep saving and figure out the delta? I eventually want the nova dvr.


https://southjersey.craigslist.org/tls/d/whitesboro-lathe/7801022164.html


Thanks for advice

At this point I am turning small stuff like handles. I don't see myself turning big bowls for a long time - if ever. 

Emily,

 

If you ask the opinion of 10 turners, you are likely to get 12 responses.

 

The 46-460, in my opinion, is a better lathe than the Comet II. I have 2 – 46-460 lathes and I like them very much – even more than the Laguna 1216 that I teach on at Rockler. So my recommendation  is to repair the 46-460 and save your money for a full-size lathe down the road. The reverse problem is likely the switch and a replacement is available from ereplacementparts.com for $8.99. I couldn’t see from your picture what the problem is with the hand wheel, but can likely be repaired as well.

 

The Comet II is a little under powered at ¾ HP and will stall with larger turnings.  That being said, the package he is offering is certainly worth $400.

 

If you want to consider other lathes, the Nova Comet 14 DR is a better choice as it  has a 14” swing and 18-1/2” between centers. It is also 1 HP.  The current price at Rockler is $769. I’ve taught on this lathe and like it. We also have 2 of these in the turning center at the church.

 

The Laguna 1216 is also an excellent lathe. It would be my second choice for a midi lathe. The current price at Rockler is $899.

 

I would stay away from Jet lathes as I don’t believe that they are reliable.

 

Rikon is a good brand. We have a number of Rikon lathes at the turning center. The 70-150VSR (12” x 16” – 1 HP) is about $800.

 

If you can bring your lathe to me in Moorestown, I will take a look and see if it can be repaired.

 

Doug

 

Douglas W. Cummings

Cummings Computer Services

138 Bretonian Drive

Brick, NJ 08723

T. 732.691.3553

 

To me it really depends on what you want to turn. It only has a 3/4hp which will struggle with larger pieces. They were around $500-$600 new they have since been updated


What it does have going for it is a scroll chuck which are helpful in different types of turning applications.


Looking back when I bought my lathe I wish I had spent a little extra and gone with a bigger lathe because I have maxed out the abilities that my lathe has

Hi


My delta 46-460 is being a pain and I'm thinking of trying a different lathe. The reverse does not work on it and there is an issue with the handwheel.

I came across this on Craigslist, but I'm getting mixed feedback on whether it's actually a good lathe or not. The guy said he never used it and it does come with extras.


Is this worth it(was thinking of offering 400) or better to keep saving and figure out the delta? I eventually want the nova dvr.


https://southjersey.craigslist.org/tls/d/whitesboro-lathe/7801022164.html


Thanks for advice

Return to Forum